Steve's Old Fashioned PB&J

Name: Steve's Old Fashioned PB&J
Ingredients: 1 part PB Bourbon — peanut butter bourbon; 2 parts Bourbon; ½ part Strawberry liquor; 4–5 dashes Orange bitters; Strawberry — muddled

old-fashioned · bourbon

Peanut butter in bourbon sounds like a dare, and the name isn't helping my case. Keep plain bourbon at twice the PB pour, or even them up if you want the full sandwich — the muddled strawberry is doing the jam work, not the liqueur. Tastes like being eight, which is the appeal and also the problem.

Ingredients

Where there's a range: the low end is lighter, the high end is fuller.

1 partPB Bourbon — peanut butter bourbon
2 partsBourbon
½ partStrawberry liquor
4–5 dashesOrange bitters
—Strawberry — muddled

Method

Muddle fresh strawberry in the bottom of a highball glass to start. Add ice, then mix all ingredients in the glass. Enjoy!

Steve’s notes

Hint: if you want MORE PB taste, dial up the PB Bourbon and dial back the regular bourbon, or split them evenly (1 1/2 to 1 1/2).